The Questions That Steer the Storm: Governing Well in Times of Transformation

The Questions That Steer the Storm: Governing Well in Times of Transformation

Transformational moments have a strange weight. They’re not just about big decisions—they’re about unknown consequences. Strategy gets rewritten. Power gets redistributed. Certainty goes missing.

And when the winds pick up, the boardroom doesn’t get quieter. It gets louder. Risk mounts. Tensions rise. Timelines compress. And yet, the greatest threat isn’t the transformation itself—it’s the questions that go unasked.

As a Board Chair or Lead Independent Director, your value in these moments isn’t in having all the answers. It’s in holding space for the right questions. Questions that illuminate blind spots, challenge assumptions, and anchor the organization in its values while everything else shifts.

So what exactly should a board be asking during a period of transformation?

Let’s begin with a deeper truth: questions aren’t neutral. They shape attention. They signal culture. And in the boardroom, they determine whether governance becomes a ballast—or a bystander.

“What is being transformed, and what must remain sacred?”

Not all change is transformation. True transformation involves identity. It reshapes the essence of how the organization creates value, serves people, or exists in the world.

That’s why the board’s first job is to clarify scope. Is this transformation operational? Strategic? Cultural? Existential?

And then to ask: in the midst of change, what must not change? What are the non-negotiables—values, principles, promises—that define who we are?

This question doesn’t slow change. It centers it.

Because strategy without a stable core is directionless.

“Who is most impacted—and are their voices in the room?”

Transformation often comes with collateral damage. Roles vanish. Priorities shift. Customers feel ignored. Employees feel betrayed.

Boards must ask: Who are the primary stakeholders in this transformation? Who stands to lose, and who stands to gain? Whose perspective is missing from our conversations?

This isn't about performative inclusion. It’s about system integrity.

When the board fails to consider impact, blind spots grow. And when they fail to ensure impacted voices are heard, legitimacy erodes.

Your role is to widen the lens, not just sharpen the focus.

“What are we solving for, and how will we know if we’re on track?”

Transformation often begins with a vague aspiration: “We need to become more digital.” “We must pivot to new markets.” But vague goals create vague governance.

The board must push for clarity. What’s the transformation thesis? What metrics matter most? Are we optimizing for speed, scale, margin, mission?

This is where discipline matters. Without clear aims, progress is hard to measure—and accountability even harder to enforce.

Transformation isn’t just a direction. It’s a design challenge. And good design starts with clear criteria for success.

“What time horizon are we truly working within?”

Boards often underestimate how long transformation takes—and how short internal patience runs.

This creates a dangerous gap. Leadership teams make big bets, but the board applies quarterly pressure. Culture begins to shift, but directors expect immediate results. Investors want returns, but the timeline was always five years.

As Chair, you must broker realism. What’s the time horizon for results? How do we keep stakeholders engaged through ambiguity? What’s the plan if early wins don’t materialize?

Boards that govern transformation well ask about time not as a constraint—but as a condition of success.

“Are we governing the plan—or governing the energy?”

This question cuts to the core.

Most boards focus on the plan—milestones, budgets, resources. But successful transformation hinges just as much on energy—belief, trust, stamina, morale.

So ask:

• Is there alignment among the executive team?

• Is the culture ready for what’s being asked?

• Are we seeing fatigue, fear, or factionalism?

• Are leaders still energized—or just executing?

These are not soft issues. They’re strategic signals.

Because transformation doesn’t fail in the plan. It fails in the people. And your oversight must extend to both.

“Where are we resisting the transformation we say we want?”

This one requires courage. Boards and executives often say they’re committed to transformation—while unconsciously preserving the very structures that inhibit it.

• Keeping the same KPIs.

• Rewarding risk-avoidant behavior.

• Prioritizing short-term returns.

• Protecting legacy leaders from feedback.

As Chair, you must help the board see its own resistance. Are we clinging to norms that no longer serve us? Are we holding the CEO to old expectations while asking for new results?

Transformation is uncomfortable. But alignment is impossible when fear goes unnamed.

“What is the role of the board—really?”

During transformation, the line between support and interference gets blurry.

Boards must define their role clearly and revisit it often. Are we governing at the right altitude? Are we aligned with the CEO on where input is welcome—and where space is needed?

Ask:

• Are we enabling transformation—or second-guessing it?

• Are our questions helping or overwhelming?

• Are we holding the CEO accountable—or creating confusion?

Clarity here is essential. Because unclear roles lead to overreach, under-support, or both.

And transformation needs a board that’s present, not meddling. Anchoring, not steering.

“What does success feel like at the board level?”

Finally, transformation isn’t just external. It reshapes the boardroom, too.

Directors must grow alongside the change. The board itself may need to shift—its composition, its cadence, its learning curve.

So ask:

• Are we learning fast enough to stay relevant?

• Are our meeting structures fit for this level of complexity?

• Do we have the right mix of challenge and support in the room?

These are not indulgent questions. They are strategic ones.

Because a board that doesn’t transform itself won’t steward transformation in others.

Asking Questions Is Governance. Asking the Right Questions Is Leadership.

Transformation exposes every crack in governance—misalignment, mistrust, inertia, fragility.

But it also creates an opening. A chance for the board to lead with curiosity, humility, and courage.

As Chair or Lead Director, your voice matters not because it’s loud—but because it invites others in.

Your job is not to answer. It’s to unlock.

And in the boardroom, nothing unlocks transformation like the right question, asked at the right moment, with the right tone.

Because questions don’t just steer strategy. They shape the soul of governance.

Is your board asking the questions that actually move transformation?

📧 Contact our team at info@sagesims.com
📅 Schedule a no-cost consult at https://sagesims.com/connect
🔍 Learn more at https://sagesims.com